"Our churches are the 'upper room' where not only is the Last Supper renewed but Pentecost also." - - - Henri de Lubac (1947) in Catholicism, ch. 3 (last sentence). Photo: the reconstructed Upper Room in Jerusalem.

Friday, October 13, 2006

Focus on Principle, Not Appeasement, on the Latin Tridentine Mass

As the media coverage on the impending papal decree, making wider celebration of the Latin Tridentine Mass easier, mounts, let me make one point that is being ignored by too many articles I have read. I do not believe the Pope is acting primarily or solely to appease schismatic traditionalist factions. The Pope is issuing this decree because it is the right thing to do, regardless of whether it appeases or satisfies schismatic factions. Of course, reconciliation would be welcome. But the universal indult is the right thing for those still in union with the Pope. That's why he's doing it. Let the chips fall where they may. If "liberals" are offended, so be it. If some schismatics come back, great. If some or most schismatics remain dissatisfied, it's their loss. The universal indult is the right thing to do because it was self-destructive and counterproductive to make it so difficult and even virtually impossible to participate in the Tridentine Mass for so many years. It was a grave prudential error that is now being corrected, not to appease any faction but to do the right thing as a matter of principle. Liturgy develops organically, not by proscription. We are returning to that fundamental principle of liturgical common sense once again. John Paul the Great paved the way. Benedict is finishing the job.

2 comments:

Vir Speluncae Catholicus said...

Good post. I said essentially the same thing a couple of days ago.

Why in the world would The Holy Father appease a rather small demographic, at the risk of alienating a rather large percentage of clerics (especially in North America and Western Europe)?

The answer's obvious...

The only point I disagree is the title "The Great" for Pope John Paul II. Quite honestly, I find very little he did to be "great".

Lovable, grandfatherly, sometimes brilliant in his writings? Without a doubt. And in all honesty... ignored, ineffective, unwilling to discipline those that spit in his face? Absolutely.

Oswald Sobrino said...

John Paul the Great in my book and that of many others and ultimately in the long sweep of history because of the Catechism of the Catholic Church, the revolutionary Theology of the Body, and the collapse of Soviet Communism. Also setting up the first prelature in the Church: Opus Dei. And his long partnership with Joseph Ratzinger as his right hand man and now successor.